Civil War California , although officially a “Union
state,” was torn between ardent proponents of both the Union and Secessionist causes. While its
largest city, San Francisco , and its capital, Sacramento , remained staunchly pro-Union, much
of Southern
California ,
particularly the counties of Los Angeles and San Bernardino , was a hotbed of sympathy for the
Southern cause.
As war
broke out in April 1861, the Speaker Pro Tem of the California State Assembly
was Representative Dan Showalter of Mariposa County . In 1852, having reached majority
and disillusioned with home life after his mother had died, Showalter left
Pennsylvania for the gold fields of California, arriving in San Francisco in
early 1853. With his fiery red hair and piercing eyes, the talkative and
likable young miner was elected to a first term in the State Assembly in 1857.
Both in that session and in the session of 1861, to which he had again been
elected, Showalter proved himself a committed legislator, often serving on and
chairing legislative committees, and ultimately serving as Speaker Pro Tem.
Just as California remained highly partisan with the
outbreak of the Civil War, its politics had been highly charged in the years
prior. Not only had the Republican Party been recently formed—generally viewed
as an extremist abolition party at the time—but the Democratic Party, by far
the majority party, had broken into two. “Douglas Democrats,” supporters of
Stephen A. Douglas against Lincoln in the 1860 presidential election but
pro-Union, vied against the pro-secession “Breckinridge Democrats,” supporters
of John C. Breckinridge, then vice president of the United States . Showalter, along with the
controlling faction in California politics of the day, was a “Chiv,”
a member of “The Chivalry,” the pro-Southern, pro-Secession Breckinridge
supporters.
During an
attempt to pass a resolution in support of the Confederacy on the last day, May
20, of the 1861 Assembly session, the representative from San Bernardino County , 24-year-old former sheriff Charles
Piercy, became angered by what he considered a procedural insult from
Showalter. A few days later Piercy challenged Showalter to a duel. The highly
publicized duel—in spite of the fact that dueling had been outlawed in California for some time—took place on May
25, 1861 ,
in Marin County . The weapons chosen were rifles at
40 paces; after being only very nearly missed on the first shot, Showalter
called for a second shot. Piercy was hit on this second round and died several
minutes later. This was California ’s last political duel. Although
both Showalter and Piercy were Democrats and the cause of the duel was a
perceived personal insult, the Northern California press spun the duel into a Union versus Secession contest and began
its vilification of Showalter.
By the
later months of that year, hundreds of armed Californians had determined to go
eastward to aid the Confederate cause. In November 1861, Dan Showalter
captained a small advance party of one of these groups sent out to test whether
Union troops would try to prevent their movement to Texas . After close pursuit by Federal
soldiers, the Showalter party of 18 armed men was captured southeast of
Temecula, near Santa Isabel , at daybreak on November 29. After imprisonment at Fort
Yuma on the California bank of the Colorado River and signing of a loyalty oath
as a condition of parole, Showalter and companions were released on April 29,
1862, with provisions to make the ten-day journey back to “New San Pedro”— Drum
Barracks—to retrieve their horses, equipment and weapons.
Undaunted
and in spite of oaths taken, Showalter and party again headed out from Southern
California shortly after release, this time going south into Mexico and then
across to Texas, arriving at the end of 1862. Coming upon George L. Patrick of Tuolumne , California , now a Confederate cavalry captain,
Showalter enlisted as a private soldier and almost immediately distinguished
himself at the battles of Galveston and Sabine Pass fought between January 1 and 9,
1863. As a result of this action, these two ports became the only two
Confederate ports to remain free from the Union blockade through the end of the
war.
By March of
1863 there is notice that Showalter was serving as an artillery captain, and by
June of that year he had been promoted to lieutenant colonel in command of the
proposed 4th Texas Cavalry, Arizona Brigade. Although, along with
other regiments, the Arizona Brigade had been formed with the intention of
retaking New Mexico and Arizona for the Confederacy, and then
opening lines to Southern California , none of its units ever went beyond Texas ’ western border. In fact, most of
its regiments were used as reserve cavalry as needed and never even fought with
each other. Showalter’s Regiment, as the 4th Texas Cavalry was often
styled, spent late 1863 and early 1864 in engagements in Indian Territory (now Oklahoma ) and Arkansas .
In mid
1864, Showalter’s Regiment was called into service under Col. John S. “RIP”
Ford along the Rio Grande in West Texas . Over the summer months, and
largely under Showalter’s command due to a severe illness overtaking Ford for
several months, these Confederate forces pushed the occupying Union forces
southward to the coast at Brownsville and regained the Rio Grande .
By
September 1864, personal tragedy had begun to take its toll on Dan Showalter.
While successful as a miner and politician in California , his reputation had been tainted by
the May 1861 duel. His capture while leading Southern sympathizers and
subsequent imprisonment in late 1861 had only led to his further identification
as a traitor to the Union .
In February 1864, he had received, to his great surprise, a letter from Anna
Forman, a young woman with whom he appears to have been romantically attached.
His reply was taken by Union soldiers from the body of the Confederate spy shot
dead while carrying it from Texas to California , so she neither knew that her
letter had reached Showalter while he never again heard from her after his
pleas for her to write often.
Showalter
dealt with this personal tragedy by drinking. On September
9, 1864 ,
when too drunk to command, Showalter’s regiment was cannonaded from across the Rio Grande by Mexican revolutionary troops.
His troops panicked and fled; Showalter was brought to court-martial, but
acquitted when Col. Ford, his commander, declined to appear. Ford later wrote
of Showalter, “When not under the influence of liquor, he was as chivalrous a
man as ever drew a sword.”